The Pirelli P Zero AS Plus 3 is AutoView's overall winner with 104 points. It finishes in the top three across every category, picking up the win on consistency rather than a standout result in any one area. The strongest pick for drivers who want UHP-grade all-season performance without compromising any single attribute.
Strong: Wet Braking, Dry Lane Change, Subj. Noise, Noise
Record by discipline
Where the Pirelli P Zero AS+ 3 finished in each measured discipline, across every test that measured it against at least two other tyres. Field beaten is the share of the other tyres it outranked in that measurement.
Record by discipline
Discipline
Tests
Avg finish
Field beaten
Firsts
Dry
Dry Braking
3
P3 of 7
64%
-
Dry Handling
3
P1.7 of 7
83%
2
Subj. Dry Handling
2
P1 of 8
100%
2
Dry Lane Change
1
P1 of 5
100%
1
Wet
Wet Braking
3
P2.3 of 7
79%
1
Wet Handling
2
P2 of 8
85%
-
Subj. Wet Handling
2
P1.5 of 8
92%
1
Snow
Snow Braking
1
P7 of 9
25%
-
Snow Handling
1
P7 of 9
25%
-
Ice
Ice Braking
1
P6 of 9
38%
-
Comfort
Subj. Comfort
3
P2 of 7
78%
1
Subj. Noise
3
P1.3 of 7
94%
2
Noise
1
P1 of 5
100%
1
Value
Wear
1
P1 of 7
100%
1
Value
1
P5 of 7
33%
-
Head-to-head record
Overall finishing position against the tyres that have most often shared a test with the Pirelli P Zero AS+ 3. Only tyres tested alongside it at least three times are listed.
Across three independent UHP all-season comparisons, the Pirelli P Zero AS Plus 3 shows consistently elite overall performance (average overall position 1.3), winning two tests outright (1/5 in 2025 AutoView; 1/9 in 2024 Tire Rack) and earning a “Highly recommended” award in 2023 Tyre Reviews (2/7). The pattern behind the strong overall results is repeatable top-tier handling/driver feel in dry and wet conditions, plus class-leading refinement scores (noise/comfort) in the larger Tire Rack and AutoView datasets.
Its main limitation is winter capability: in the only test with deep winter metrics (2024 Tire Rack), it placed 7/9 in both snow braking (+17.2% from best) and snow handling (+9.6%), with only mid-pack ice braking (6/9, +5.1%). Separately, value is a recurring weakness when assessed (2023 Tyre Reviews: price 6/7, +83.9% vs best; value 5/7, +47.2% vs best), meaning its performance focus comes at a notable cost premium.
Performance Strengths
Dry Handling & Steering PrecisionStrongDetails
1st place dry handling in 2024 Tire Rack (29.93 s, 1/9) with 1st place subjective dry handling (8 pts, 1/9)
1st place dry handling in 2023 Tyre Reviews (42.14 s, 1/7) with 1st place subjective dry handling (100 pts, 1/7)
1st place dry lane change in 2025 AutoView (104 km/h, 1/5)
Wet Grip & Wet Handling BalanceStrongDetails
1st place wet braking in 2023 Tyre Reviews (46.7 m, 1/7) and 2nd place wet handling (47.83 s, +0.9% from best)
2nd place wet handling in 2024 Tire Rack (32.08 s, +1.2% from best, 2/9) with 1st place subjective wet handling (8 pts, 1/9)
2nd place wet braking in 2025 AutoView (26.75 m, +7.6% from best, 2/5)
Comfort & Noise RefinementStrongDetails
1st place subjective comfort in 2024 Tire Rack (7.75 pts, 1/9) and 1st place subjective noise (8.25 pts, 1/9)
1st place objective noise in 2025 AutoView (62.6 dB, 1/5) and 1st place subjective noise (7 pts, 1/5)
Wear / Longevity (when evaluated)ModerateDetails
1st place wear in 2023 Tyre Reviews (50,000 km, 1/7)
7th place snow braking in 2024 Tire Rack (29.58 m, +17.2% from best, 7/9)
7th place snow handling in 2024 Tire Rack (59.36 s, +9.6% from best, 7/9)
6th place ice braking in 2024 Tire Rack (13.84 m, +5.1% from best, 6/9)
Value / Purchase PriceModerateDetails
6th place price in 2023 Tyre Reviews (277.6, +83.9% from best, 6/7)
5th place value in 2023 Tyre Reviews (5.55 price/1000, +47.2% from best, 5/7)
Braking Consistency vs Top Brakers (Dry & Wet)MinorDetails
Dry braking was 3rd in all three tests: 2025 AutoView (37.85 m, +6.2%, 3/5), 2024 Tire Rack (34.75 m, +1.8%, 3/9), 2023 Tyre Reviews (35.2 m, +2%, 3/7)
Wet braking ranged from best-in-test to mid-pack: 1st in 2023 Tyre Reviews (46.7 m, 1/7) but 4th in 2024 Tire Rack (41.45 m, +5.4%, 4/9)
Every test, newest first 3
Strong = top two of the field in that measurement. Weak = bottom two.
The Pirelli P Zero AS Plus 3 is AutoView's overall winner with 104 points. It finishes in the top three across every category, picking up the win on consistency rather than a standout result in any one area. The strongest pick for drivers who want UHP-grade all-season performance without compromising any single attribute.
The Pirelli P Zero AS Plus 3 provided a very positive road ride experience, absorbing most impacts, smoothing over bumps, and keeping the cabin exceptionally quiet with no strong tread noise. The steering was natural and responsive—quick but not over-eager. This intuitive nature carried over to the wet track, where the steering was effortlessly natural to use, even at the limit, and was well-matched to the tyre's grip level. The tyre felt balanced, with the front and rear axles working in union, making it the most pleasant to drive in the wet. On the dry track, these traits remained, and it added top objective lap times to its accomplishments. In winter conditions, the P Zero AS Plus 3 was not quite as confidence-inspiring. While the steering remained responsive, the tyre felt like it wanted to be driven with the rear axle, and its ceiling for functional traction was lower than other tyres in the test.