The 2018 Auto Bild SUV / 4x4 winter tyre test has used an Audi Q5 to test ten 235/60 R18 winter tyres, with the Goodyear UltraGrip Performance Gen-1 SUV proving to be the best tyre on test thanks to a balanced all-round performance.
Surprisingly Pirelli edged out Continental to second place, with a brilliant result for the Pirelli Scorpion Winter. This tyre has been on the market a number of years now, and historically hasn't tested as well as Goodyear or Continental, so there must have been and update for the 2018 winter season. The Continental Winter Contact TS850P SUV rounded out the top three, with its only real weakness appearing during the dry braking tests.
The other notable result was the new Achilles W101X. Budget tyres like this Achilles historically perform excellently in snow testing, but end up with dangerously long wet and dry braking distances, but in this test the Achilles held its own, finishing second during dry braking and beating the established names of Toyo and Firestone during wet braking. Impressive when you consider a set is nearly half the price of the most expensive tyre on test...
Dry
The Pirelli winter tyre proved to be the master of dry testing, but still lagged significantly behind the reference summer tyre again highlighting the dry penalty siped winter tyres bring.
Dry Braking
Dry braking in meters
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
35.5 m | -5.30 m |
| 40.8 m | Best | |
| 41.8 m | +1.00 m | |
| 42.6 m | +1.80 m | |
| 42.7 m | +1.90 m | |
| 42.7 m | +1.90 m | |
| 43.1 m | +2.30 m | |
| 43.2 m | +2.40 m | |
| 43.3 m | +2.50 m | |
| 45.2 m | +4.40 m | |
| 45.5 m | +4.70 m |
The difference between best and worst was 28.2% (10 m ≈ 2.2 Car Lengths).
Dry Handling
Dry Handling Average Speed
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
98.8 km/h | +2.40 km/h |
| 96.4 km/h | Best | |
| 96.1 km/h | -0.30 km/h | |
| 96 km/h | -0.40 km/h | |
| 95.9 km/h | -0.50 km/h | |
| 95.8 km/h | -0.60 km/h | |
| 95.7 km/h | -0.70 km/h | |
| 95.5 km/h | -0.90 km/h | |
| 95.2 km/h | -1.20 km/h | |
| 94.6 km/h | -1.80 km/h | |
| 94.3 km/h | -2.10 km/h |
The difference between best and worst was 4.6% (4.5 Km/H).
Wet
The summer tyres advantage continued in the wet, albeit the gap was smaller. The top three tyres overall were all stars of the wet testing, showing how important wet performance is to winter tyre testing.
Wet Braking
Wet braking in meters
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
45.9 m | -1.60 m |
| 47.5 m | Best | |
| 47.8 m | +0.30 m | |
| 47.8 m | +0.30 m | |
| 47.8 m | +0.30 m | |
| 48.6 m | +1.10 m | |
| 48.7 m | +1.20 m | |
| 49.9 m | +2.40 m | |
| 50 m | +2.50 m | |
| 50.4 m | +2.90 m | |
| 52.2 m | +4.70 m |
The difference between best and worst was 13.7% (6.3 m ≈ 1.4 Car Lengths).
Wet Handling
Wet Handling Average Speed
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
88.3 km/h | +1.30 km/h |
| 87 km/h | Best | |
| 86.4 km/h | -0.60 km/h | |
| 86.4 km/h | -0.60 km/h | |
| 86.2 km/h | -0.80 km/h | |
| 85.9 km/h | -1.10 km/h | |
| 85.1 km/h | -1.90 km/h | |
| 84.4 km/h | -2.60 km/h | |
| 84.3 km/h | -2.70 km/h | |
| 83.9 km/h | -3.10 km/h | |
| 83.3 km/h | -3.70 km/h |
The difference between best and worst was 5.7% (5 Km/H).
Straight Aqua
Float Speed in Km/H
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
80.3 km/h | +1.80 km/h |
| 78.5 km/h | Best | |
| 78.3 km/h | -0.20 km/h | |
| 75.3 km/h | -3.20 km/h | |
| 75.1 km/h | -3.40 km/h | |
| 74.6 km/h | -3.90 km/h | |
| 74.4 km/h | -4.10 km/h | |
| 74 km/h | -4.50 km/h | |
| 74 km/h | -4.50 km/h | |
| 73.9 km/h | -4.60 km/h | |
| 69.3 km/h | -9.20 km/h |
The difference between best and worst was 13.7% (11 Km/H).
Snow
Unsurprisingly the summer tyre was at a huge disadvantage in the snow testing. Continental proved to have the best snow braking, where Nokian was the fastest around the snow handling lap.
Snow Braking
Snow braking in meters
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 26.7 m | Best | |
| 27.7 m | +1.00 m | |
| 27.7 m | +1.00 m | |
| 28 m | +1.30 m | |
| 28.8 m | +2.10 m | |
| 29.1 m | +2.40 m | |
| 29.1 m | +2.40 m | |
| 29.4 m | +2.70 m | |
| 29.7 m | +3.00 m | |
| 31.2 m | +4.50 m | |
RefReference Summer |
81.7 m | +55.00 m |
The difference between best and worst was 206% (55 m ≈ 12.2 Car Lengths).
Snow Handling
Snow handling average speed
Higher is better ↑| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
| 52.6 km/h | Best | |
| 51.3 km/h | -1.30 km/h | |
| 51 km/h | -1.60 km/h | |
| 50.9 km/h | -1.70 km/h | |
| 50.7 km/h | -1.90 km/h | |
| 50.7 km/h | -1.90 km/h | |
| 50.1 km/h | -2.50 km/h | |
| 50.1 km/h | -2.50 km/h | |
| 49.2 km/h | -3.40 km/h | |
| 48.6 km/h | -4.00 km/h | |
RefReference Summer |
28.8 km/h | -23.80 km/h |
The difference between best and worst was 45.2% (23.8 Km/H).
Environment
The Pirelli bended an excellent dry and wet performance with the lowest rolling resistance on test, an impressive feat!
Rolling Resistance
Rolling resistance in kg t
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best | Extra fuel / year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7.66 kg/t | Best | £0 | |
| 7.69 kg/t | +0.03 kg/t | £2 | |
RefReference Summer |
7.79 kg/t | +0.13 kg/t | £7 |
| 7.82 kg/t | +0.16 kg/t | £9 | |
| 8 kg/t | +0.34 kg/t | £20 | |
| 8.34 kg/t | +0.68 kg/t | £39 | |
| 8.38 kg/t | +0.72 kg/t | £41 | |
| 8.42 kg/t | +0.76 kg/t | £44 | |
| 8.47 kg/t | +0.81 kg/t | £47 | |
| 8.85 kg/t | +1.19 kg/t | £68 | |
| 8.86 kg/t | +1.20 kg/t | £69 |
The difference between best and worst was 15.7% (1.2 kg / t). Over 19,000 km a year at £1.45/L, the Achilles Winter 101 X uses about 48 L (£69) more fuel than the Pirelli Scorpion Winter.
Adjust the assumptions
Calculated estimates, not additional measurements. Use the controls to explore the assumptions.
Unusually the summer tyre was the quietest on test.
Noise
External noise in dB
Lower is better ↓| Position / Tyre | Result | Gap to best |
|---|---|---|
RefReference Summer |
69.8 dB | -0.70 dB |
| 70.5 dB | Best | |
| 70.8 dB | +0.30 dB | |
| 70.9 dB | +0.40 dB | |
| 71.4 dB | +0.90 dB | |
| 71.4 dB | +0.90 dB | |
| 72.4 dB | +1.90 dB | |
| 72.7 dB | +2.20 dB | |
| 72.8 dB | +2.30 dB | |
| 72.8 dB | +2.30 dB | |
| 73.6 dB | +3.10 dB |
The difference between best and worst was 5.4% (3.8 dB).
The budget Achilles was by far the cheapest set of tyres on test, with the Michelin the most expensive. Sadly Auto Bild didn't include any wear testing, so we can't judge which tyre is best value overall.
Results
Goodyear UltraGrip Performance SUV Gen-1
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 11 |
| Wet | 13 |
| Snow | 12 |
| Comfort | 12 |
| Rolling Resistance | 10 |
| Noise | 10 |
Total: 68
- Price
- 595.00
Pirelli Scorpion Winter
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 12 |
| Wet | 13 |
| Snow | 11 |
| Comfort | 10 |
| Rolling Resistance | 14 |
| Noise | 11 |
Total: 71
- Price
- 635.00
Continental WinterContact TS 850 P SUV
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 10 |
| Wet | 12 |
| Snow | 13 |
| Comfort | 10 |
| Rolling Resistance | 14 |
| Noise | 10 |
Total: 69
- Price
- 630.00
Fulda Kristall Control SUV
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 11 |
| Wet | 12 |
| Snow | 12 |
| Comfort | 9 |
| Rolling Resistance | 12 |
| Noise | 10 |
Total: 66
- Price
- 485.00
Dunlop Winter Sport 5 SUV
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 11 |
| Wet | 13 |
| Snow | 11 |
| Comfort | 11 |
| Rolling Resistance | 10 |
| Noise | 10 |
Total: 66
- Price
- 665.00
Nokian WR SUV 4
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 10 |
| Wet | 10 |
| Snow | 14 |
| Comfort | 9 |
| Rolling Resistance | 13 |
| Noise | 11 |
Total: 67
- Price
- 635.00
Michelin Latitude Alpin 2
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 8 |
| Wet | 11 |
| Snow | 14 |
| Comfort | 12 |
| Rolling Resistance | 8 |
| Noise | 12 |
Total: 65
- Price
- 675.00
Firestone Destination Winter SUV
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 8 |
| Wet | 9 |
| Snow | 13 |
| Comfort | 8 |
| Rolling Resistance | 10 |
| Noise | 12 |
Total: 60
- Price
- 485.00
Achilles Winter 101 X
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 11 |
| Wet | 10 |
| Snow | 11 |
| Comfort | 9 |
| Rolling Resistance | 8 |
| Noise | 12 |
Total: 61
- Price
- 350.00
Toyo Snowprox S954 SUV
235/60 R18All discipline results (6)
| Test | Result |
|---|---|
| Dry | 10 |
| Wet | 10 |
| Snow | 9 |
| Comfort | 11 |
| Rolling Resistance | 10 |
| Noise | 9 |
Total: 59
- Price
- 480.00

Discussion