Auto Bild Performance, the German version of EVO magazine have put together the tyre test EVO should have. 7 wide 225/40 R18 tyres on a 260bhp Mazda 3 MPS.
On test are the usual premium brands, with only Bridgestone missing from the "big 6". Also included a midrange Hankook and a budget Rockstone.
Do budget winters work in the UK?
Perhaps the most interesting part of the test was the inclusion of a performance budget winter tyre. The UK, known as one of the largest buyers of budget tyres, has been importing budget winter tyres in masses this year. With the UK winters being appropriately 40% dry, 45% wet and 15% snow, seriously sacrificing wet weather performance for snow performance would be an oversight, yet that's exactly what this test shows with the Rockstone getting the lowest possible wet performance score.While not all budgets are equal, it's important to do research when considering any tyre to ensure you get balanced performance.
Results
- 3PMSF: no
Excellent winter tyres with dynamic handling characteristics. Highest safety reserves in aquaplaning, with short braking distances on both wet and dry roads.
Total: 24
Dry
7
Wet
8
Snow
9
- 3PMSF: no
Top winter tyres with excellent traction and shortest braking distances on snow covered slopes. Stable cornering with safe driving characteristics. Excellent aquaplaning properties
Total: 23
Dry
7
Wet
7
Snow
9
- 3PMSF: no
Balanced sports winter tyre. Stable cornering and safe qualities on snow, excellent steering precision with good dynamic response and handling
Total: 21
Dry
7
Wet
7
Snow
7
- 3PMSF: no
Sport handling qualities on wet and dry track, short braking distance and pleasant ride comfort
Understeer on snow, only average aquaplaning result
Total: 21
Dry
7
Wet
7
Snow
7
- 3PMSF: no
Impressive handling qualities on snow, good stering precision and short braking distances on dry roads
Slightly longer braking distances on wet roads and a high rolling resistance
Total: 21
Dry
7
Wet
6
Snow
8
- 3PMSF: no
Good on snow, high steering precision and cornering stability on dry roads. Low rolling resistance
Understeer and long braking in the wet, average aquaplaning results
Total: 18
Dry
8
Wet
4
Snow
6
- 3PMSF: no
Good snow performance
Perhaps the perfect example of why budget winter tyres struggle in the UK climate. While this tyre was excellent in the snow it was rated dangerous in the wet with massive braking distances and terrible aquaplaning properties. Overall Autobild called the tyre "defective"!
Total: 18.1
Dry
8
Wet
0.1
Snow
10