Menu

Test source Auto Zeitung

2017 All Season VS Winter Tyre Test

Joint test winnersContinental WinterContact TS 860 Michelin CrossClimate

The German publication Auto Zeitung have just published their 2017 all season tyre test, and it might be the most UK relevant tyre test we've ever seen.

Tyres tested
11
Tested size
205/55 R16
Disciplines
9

At a glance

Tyre shortlist

11 Tyres tested

Published finishing positions, with the strengths and considerations from this test. Owner reviews cover other sizes and driving conditions.

Joint1st

Continental WinterContact TS 860

+Excellent performance in the snow (better than any of the all-season tires), good braking and handling in the wet, low rolling resistance

−Poor dry handling

Read full verdict
Joint1st

Michelin CrossClimate

+Good acceleration and braking on snow, good in the wet, very short dry braking, excellent dry handling

−Weak snow handling

Read full verdict
2nd

Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-2

+Even better than the winter under snow braking, excellent snow traction, good wet braking, low rolling resistance

−Relatively long dry braking and poor dry handling

3rd

BFGoodrich g-Grip All-Season 2

+Good acceleration and braking on snow, good handling on wet and dry roads, low rolling resistance

−Poor snow handling

Read full verdict
4th

Nokian Weatherproof

+Almost as good as a full winter in the snow, good aquaplaning resistance, low rolling resistance

−Average braking and handling in the wet

5th

Uniroyal AllSeasonExpert

+Good snow handling, good wet braking, good resistance to aquaplaning

−Longest braking in the dry, and poor dry handling

Read full verdict
6th

Vredestein Quatrac 5

+Good wet and dry handling

−Weak resistance to aquaplaning, poor lateral snow grip, loudest tyre on test

Read full verdict
7th

Falken EUROALL SEASON AS200

+Good wet handling

−Weak grip in the snow, long dry braking, high rolling resistance

Read full verdict
8th

Pirelli Cinturato All Season

+Good resistance to aquaplaning and good wet braking

−Understeer in the dry, longest braking distances in the snow

9th

Hankook Kinergy 4S

+Good dry handling

−Poor snow handling, longest wet braking, poor wet handling

Read full verdict
10th

Toyo Celsius

+None mentioned

−Poor snow handling, long dry braking

Read full verdict

Tyre shortlist

Compare selected tyres

2017 All Season VS Winter Tyre Test · 205/55 R16

Explore the complete results →

The full test

The evidence behind the verdict

The German publication Auto Zeitung have just published their 2017 all season tyre test, and it might be the most UK relevant tyre test we've seen this year.

First, they're testing in the most popular 205/55 R16 size using a FWD Audi A3, which represents a large slice of our car market. Secondly, they've managed to include ten all season patterns, which is more than most all season tyre tests manage, but the icing on the cake is the winter tyre included for reference is the multiple award winning Continental WinterContact TS 860.

We've mentioned a number of times that the Continental WinterContact range is not only consistently the best tested winter tyres on the market, but could also be considered as the best "winter-bias all season tyre" available due to its remarkable ability to work well in the snow, and the wet. This test confirms that, but it faces close competition from the only summer-bias all season tyre on the market, the Michelin CrossClimate

Dry

There are no surprises during the dry testing. The summer-bias Michelin CrossClimate makes good on its promise of behaving like a summer tyre in dry conditions, and aces both the dry braking and dry handling tests by some margin.

BF Goodrich have a good showing, placing second under dry braking and third in dry handling, and the Continental WinterContact TS860 and Goodyear Vector 4Season Gen 2 both finish mid pack in a closely contested group.

Dry Braking

Dry braking in meters

Lower is better ↓
Dry Braking
Position / TyreResultGap to best
39.4 m Best
42.9 m +3.50 m
43.8 m +4.40 m
44.6 m +5.20 m
45.1 m +5.70 m
45.1 m +5.70 m
45.3 m +5.90 m
45.5 m +6.10 m
46.4 m +7.00 m
46.7 m +7.30 m
47.2 m +7.80 m

The difference between best and worst was 19.8% (7.8 m ≈ 1.7 Car Lengths).

Dry Handling

Dry handling time in seconds

Lower is better ↓
Dry Handling
Position / TyreResultGap to best
59.7 s Best
59.8 s +0.10 s
60 s +0.30 s
60.1 s +0.40 s
60.1 s +0.40 s
60.4 s +0.70 s
60.4 s +0.70 s
60.6 s +0.90 s
60.7 s +1.00 s
60.9 s +1.20 s
60.9 s +1.20 s

All the tyres in the Dry Handling test finished less than 3% apart.

Wet

The wet braking confirms why the Continental WinterContact TS860 is currently unbeaten in winter tyre testing, it wins the wet handling lap by over a second, and finishes joint first in wet braking. While the Michelin couldn't quite match the Continental and Goodyear during wet braking, it still finishes a respectable fourth place overall, and places second overall in wet handling.

Wet Braking

Wet braking in meters

Lower is better ↓
Wet Braking
Position / TyreResultGap to best
54.1 m Best
54.1 m Best
58.3 m +4.20 m
58.4 m +4.30 m
59.1 m +5.00 m
59.5 m +5.40 m
60.2 m +6.10 m
61.1 m +7.00 m
63.1 m +9.00 m
64.8 m +10.70 m
65.3 m +11.20 m

The difference between best and worst was 20.7% (11.2 m ≈ 2.5 Car Lengths).

Wet Handling

Wet handling time in seconds

Lower is better ↓
Wet Handling
Position / TyreResultGap to best
88.7 s Best
89.8 s +1.10 s
90.9 s +2.20 s
91.4 s +2.70 s
91.5 s +2.80 s
92.1 s +3.40 s
92.4 s +3.70 s
92.4 s +3.70 s
92.5 s +3.80 s
92.5 s +3.80 s
92.8 s +4.10 s

The difference between best and worst was 4.6% (4.1 s).

Straight Aqua

Float Speed in Km/H

Higher is better ↑
Straight Aqua
Position / TyreResultGap to best
74.3 km/h Best
71.7 km/h -2.60 km/h
71.1 km/h -3.20 km/h
69.9 km/h -4.40 km/h
69.5 km/h -4.80 km/h
67.9 km/h -6.40 km/h
66.6 km/h -7.70 km/h
66.2 km/h -8.10 km/h
66 km/h -8.30 km/h
64.3 km/h -10.00 km/h
61.9 km/h -12.40 km/h

The difference between best and worst was 16.7% (12.4 Km/H).

Snow

The Goodyear all season tyre managed to beat the Continental winter tyre during the snow braking test, and the Nokian all season tyre just edges out the Continental during snow handling. The summer bias Michelin managed a respectable fifth place during the snow braking, despite its summer bias, but the lack of sipes were highlighted in the snow handling test, where the Michelin could only finish ninth overall.

Snow Braking

Snow braking in meters

Lower is better ↓
Snow Braking
Position / TyreResultGap to best
21.1 m Best
21.2 m +0.10 m
21.4 m +0.30 m
21.7 m +0.60 m
21.8 m +0.70 m
23 m +1.90 m
23.3 m +2.20 m
23.3 m +2.20 m
23.4 m +2.30 m
23.6 m +2.50 m
24.8 m +3.70 m

The difference between best and worst was 17.5% (3.7 m ≈ 0.8 Car Lengths).

Snow Handling

Snow handling time in seconds

Lower is better ↓
Snow Handling
Position / TyreResultGap to best
97 s Best
97.1 s +0.10 s
98.4 s +1.40 s
100.6 s +3.60 s
101.1 s +4.10 s
101.9 s +4.90 s
102.9 s +5.90 s
103.2 s +6.20 s
103.5 s +6.50 s
103.6 s +6.60 s
103.7 s +6.70 s

The difference between best and worst was 6.9% (6.7 s).

Other

The Nokian proved to have the lowest fuel use on test, and all eleven tyres were within 2db during the external drive by noise test.

Rolling Resistance

Rolling resistance in kg t

Lower is better ↓
Rolling Resistance
Position / TyreResultGap to bestExtra fuel / year
7.77 kg/t Best £0
7.87 kg/t +0.10 kg/t £6
8.16 kg/t +0.39 kg/t £22
8.41 kg/t +0.64 kg/t £36
8.63 kg/t +0.86 kg/t £49
8.67 kg/t +0.90 kg/t £51
8.75 kg/t +0.98 kg/t £56
8.89 kg/t +1.12 kg/t £64
9.36 kg/t +1.59 kg/t £90
9.64 kg/t +1.87 kg/t £106
9.78 kg/t +2.01 kg/t £114

The difference between best and worst was 25.9% (2.01 kg / t). Over 19,000 km a year at £1.45/L, the Hankook Kinergy 4S uses about 79 L (£114) more fuel than the Nokian Weatherproof.

Adjust the assumptions

Calculated estimates, not additional measurements. Use the controls to explore the assumptions.

19,000 km
£1.45/L
Estimates based on typical driving conditions. Rolling resistance accounts for approximately 20% of IC vehicle fuel consumption and 25% of EV energy consumption. Actual savings vary based on driving style, vehicle weight, road conditions, and tyre age. For comparative purposes only. Lifetime savings based on a 40,000km / 25,000 mile tread life.

Noise

External noise in dB

Lower is better ↓
Noise
Position / TyreResultGap to best
71 dB Best
71 dB Best
71 dB Best
71 dB Best
71 dB Best
72 dB +1.00 dB
72 dB +1.00 dB
72 dB +1.00 dB
72 dB +1.00 dB
72 dB +1.00 dB
73 dB +2.00 dB

All the tyres in the Noise test finished less than 3% apart.

Results

Joint 1st

Continental WinterContact TS 860

205/55 R16
Continental WinterContact TS 860
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry113
Wet149
Snow140
Comfort9
Rolling Resistance22
Noise10
Overall402

Total: 845

Joint 1st

Michelin CrossClimate

205/55 R16
Michelin CrossClimate
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry138
Wet124
Snow96
Comfort7
Rolling Resistance18
Noise9
Overall358

Total: 750

2nd

Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-2

205/55 R16
Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-2
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry110
Wet118
Snow126
Comfort6
Rolling Resistance24
Noise9
Overall354

Total: 747

3rd

BFGoodrich g-Grip All-Season 2

205/55 R16
BFGoodrich g-Grip All-Season 2
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry123
Wet111
Snow111
Comfort8
Rolling Resistance20
Noise10
Overall345

Total: 728

4th

Nokian Weatherproof

205/55 R16
Nokian Weatherproof
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry108
Wet95
Snow134
Comfort6
Rolling Resistance25
Noise9
Overall337

Total: 714

5th

Uniroyal AllSeasonExpert

205/55 R16
Uniroyal AllSeasonExpert
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry95
Wet103
Snow123
Comfort7
Rolling Resistance17
Noise10
Overall321

Total: 676

6th

Vredestein Quatrac 5

205/55 R16
Vredestein Quatrac 5
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry116
Wet98
Snow88
Comfort7
Rolling Resistance18
Noise8
Overall295

Total: 630

7th

Falken EUROALL SEASON AS200

205/55 R16
Falken EUROALL SEASON AS200
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry90
Wet112
Snow82
Comfort6
Rolling Resistance12
Noise10
Overall284

Total: 596

8th

Pirelli Cinturato All Season

205/55 R16
Pirelli Cinturato All Season
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry104
Wet110
Snow67
Comfort8
Rolling Resistance18
Noise9
Overall281

Total: 597

9th

Hankook Kinergy 4S

205/55 R16
Hankook Kinergy 4S
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry111
Wet85
Snow82
Comfort7
Rolling Resistance12
Noise9
Overall278

Total: 584

10th

Toyo Celsius

205/55 R16
Toyo Celsius
All discipline results (7)
TestResult
Dry103
Wet79
Snow88
Comfort7
Rolling Resistance14
Noise10
Overall270

Total: 571

More tyre tests

Cross-check this test

All tyre tests

Where these tyres were tested again, and how the verdict held up.

Discussion

23 comments
  1. Piotr Lotto archived

    I live in central Poland (flat). During last 5 years We've only experienced rather harsh winter once. Usually snow lasts less than a month. It's more like wet and cold or very cold.
    I have a trouble with my Mazda mx5. Obviously I can't use HP summer tires (Michelin PS4) cause this would be absolutely lethal. I use Goodyear UG 8 performace, but it has plenty of disadvantages. The tradeoff in dry performance is noticeable. The real issue is that the car is very tail happy. This might be rather amusing, but it just kills the tires way too fast. During last winter I lost 5mm of tread. For this year I bought two new tires, but this solution is an enviromental and financial disaster, and I believe it is not worth it. The other issue is size (205/45/17) which strongly cuts availability of decent winter tires. I feel like manufacturers sort of gave up this size (UG8 performance debuted sth like 8 years ago).
    Take all of this into account, and I started to wonder if I can use all season tires instead of winter tires? For example "quatrac 5" cost half the money of my winter tires, and probably runs much better on dry/wet roads.
    So the question is:
    What would be your recommendation for performace/fun car that even in winter gives you this "fun" factor, and which does not have to be used in winter storms?
    Please take into account this horrible 205/45/17.

    #5427
    1. TyreReviews Piotr Lotto archived

      In that size the only thing close to a summer tyre is the CrossClimate+, but I'm not sure if that'll have the snow / ice grip you need

      #5428
      1. Piotr Lotto TyreReviews archived

        I bought crossclimate+ for my daily car (Fiat 500). This winter will show whether it was a crazy choice or not. But since I have those PilotSport4 for Mazda, I don't care THAT much for hot summer performance.
        My previous tires (for 500) were quatrac 3, and I was more than happy with them. The only issue was 25+ degrees celsius performance. That's why I was thinking about Vredesteins.....but 185 bhp RWD may be different than small Fiat ;)
        I have to make a choice for the next winter. There's no way I'll be paying for 2 expensive winter tires every single year.

        So if you were me would you stay with UG8 performance or switched to quatrac 5?

        #5429
        1. TyreReviews Piotr Lotto archived

          Honestly, I'm not sure there will be a huge difference. There's a new Quatrac 5 replacement due next year so if you can wait, I'd wait for that

          #5430
          1. Piotr Lotto TyreReviews archived

            Thank you for your opinion, which I highly value. So I'll wait.
            Thanks to your website and videos I chose both Michelins, and am happy with them.

            PS PilotSport4 is probably the best tire mx5 can ever get.

            #5431
            1. TyreReviews Piotr Lotto archived

              Thank you for the kind words, I'm glad you're getting on with your tyres :)

              #5432
  2. Malmboy archived

    I live in Lofoten islands, Northern Norway. Wet and relatively mild artic climate locally, yet icy roads mid winter. For late winter/early spring (Mid-late March to mid May) and late automn (october to end of november), I find it hard to decide whether or not to buy a set of Michelin CrossClimate / Continental Winter Contact TS 860. Local roads are really narrow with many unobtrusive and sharp curves. To me, ice and slush is a bigger concern than snow. I usually drive with "nordic" studded tyres from November 1 to May 1. As you probably know, studded tyres is not the king of dry or wet roads and because of the small margins on those narrow roads, I guess Michelin CrossClimate or Continental Winter Contact could be the answer. Question is, is it safe to drive on those tyres when I occasionally encounter ice or slushy (a blend of ice/water and snow) roads, typically in better parts of the road, in speed 46 to 50 mph?

    #3464
    1. TyreReviews Malmboy archived

      Without having experienced your climates it would be difficult to answer with a high level of accuracy, but in your scenario I'd certainly be looking at the TS860 rather than the CrossClimate as it has better ice performance. As I'm sure you're aware, the ice performance of a central european winter is nowhere near a studded tyre, so you would still need to be mindful when driving.

      #3467
      1. Malmboy TyreReviews archived

        Thank you! I have now looked into Continental WinterContact TS 860 and a review in Auto Express comparing all season tyres, CrossClimate and the TS 860. I have no doubt that WinterContact TS 860 is the best choice. I plan to use it from April to end of May and from September to end of October.

        Thank you again for pushing me in that direction (the TS860 rather than CrossClimate) :)

        #3471
        1. TyreReviews Malmboy archived

          No problem, glad you find the site useful :) Let me know how you find them!

          #3472
          1. Malmboy TyreReviews archived

            I finally decided to buy a set of Continental WinterContact TS 860 S. Not so many options in wheel sizes for my Subaru Outback. I know that the TS 860 S is a little bit more tweaked for performance on dry/wet and a little less on snow/ice. My intention is still not to replace my fantastic studded tyres (Nokian Hakkapeliitta 9) in winter. Just to increase security and peace of mind in spring and autumn. I plan to change to summer tyres in June, when the temperatures is higher.

            #3497
            1. TyreReviews Malmboy archived

              Let me know how you get on, you couldn't have picked a better Euro winter tyre for the job :)

              #3498
  3. grimreaper archived

    Shame that very few of these are Star Rated for use on BMW cars and therefore not compatible with the X-Drive system, which I suspect is a growing market.

    #3076
  4. Andy Holmes archived

    If you discount rolling resistance, which to be fair would be offset by price difference, the Falken AS200 is also a top-end tyre deserved of a higher position. Take the top 4 all season, find the results from the magazine and compare; Dry braking is its worst attribute but is below 1 meter longer compared to vector and comparable also to weatherproof, the wet braking is essentially the same as the crossclimate as is snow behaviour, whilst wet braking and handling are better than weatherproof, and wet handling better than the vector...

    #2941
    1. George Andy Holmes archived

      The only top end all season tyres are the CrossClimate and the Vector. Beacause they excel in some tests and are not very bad in others.
      You compare the Falken's dry braking with the Vector and the wet braking with the CrossClimate. In my opinion, that it's nonsense. Do it the other way around and you will find out why the Falken it's a mediocre tyre (as all the other tyres for that matter). Not terrible, but it is not especially good at anything.

      #2943
      1. Andy Holmes George archived

        Yes its a jack of all trades master of none.
        However what i was saying is that performance-wise its right in the thick of it, and compared differing fields because ALL the tyres have mixed behaviours across the spectrum. Take the higher ranking Uniroyal, its much worse in the dry and worse in the wet grip-wise, but picks up points for hydroplaning in the wet. The snow performance is better, but on the whole the Falken is a more balanced tyre than the Uniroyal for central europe/uk use.
        I was just raising the point that, rolling resistance aside which is more than offset by the price, tge falken is worth more consideration to purchasers than its 7th place may suggest.

        #2944
  5. Scherz Keks archived

    I have always told my friends. They didn´t believe me that AllSeason is not, what is written on the sidewall.

    AllSeason has to be choosed more carefully, by weighing the pros and cons of each tested tyre.

    Finally Continental has released their new AllSeason tyre. But just one fucking year to late for me. I have bought 8 new tyres.

    #2920
    1. TyreReviews Scherz Keks archived

      Looking at the tests, while the new Continental AllSeasonContact is a great performing tyre, it seems to have some issues with wear.

      #2923
  6. Nico Dupuis archived

    The Michelin tyre is CrossClimate + i think not CrossClimate.

    #2903
      1. TyreReviews George archived

        The Auto Bild test is CrossClimate+, though I've listed that one as CrossClimate too so I need to update that!

        #2908
  7. Thierry Priem archived

    Note: The BFGoodrich is 100% exactly the same tyre as the Kleber Quadraxer 2... I think it's the best choice given the fact it's quite a bit cheaper than the CC from Michelin and lasts as long...

    #2881
    1. 4cvg Thierry Priem archived

      The crucial point is not that it is cheaper & lasts longer than superior rivals but that it is not greatly inferior in performance. Personally, I am always willing to pay for superior performance on parameters I prioritise.

      #2882
Rate your tyres

My tyres

Saved in this browser on this site. No account needed. Clearing browser data removes your choices.

Vehicle and size

Check the size, load and speed ratings on your vehicle. Saving a size does not confirm fitment.

Saved tyres

Save tyres from a tyre page, test or comparison to keep them here.

Select 2–8 saved tyres. Ranked comparisons require at least two shared tests.

Where to buy

Affiliate links: if you buy, we may earn a commission. It never changes our tests, scores or recommendations. How we stay independent