When it's dry, it is good enough. It's a bit noisier than the summer eco tyre Hankook kinergy eco2 I had previously.
In the wet it feels great. Some light offroading and mud/grass driving is also great, much better than the summer tyre.
Snow handling is okay/good. Ice is a bit worse, but still okay. Thankfully we don't see that often.
For our case, I believe it's better to have a 3-4yr old all-season tyre compared to using ~6-7 yr old winter tyre. That's not only in terms of grip, but also about saving money - I don't need to either have another set of rims or pay someone to change the tyres. Just once a year or so, it's probably a good idea to rotate the tyres and that's it.

