Menu

A newer edition of this test is out: 2026 Auto Express All Season Tyre Test

Test source Auto Express

2017 Auto Express All Season Tyre Test

Overall test winnerMichelin CrossClimate+

The 2017 Auto Express all season tyre test is a wonderful mix of eight 205/55 R16 all season tyres, the Dunlop Sport BluResponse summer tyre and the Continental WinterContact TS860 winter tyre.

Tyres tested
8
Tested size
205/55 R16

At a glance

Tyre shortlist

8 Tyres tested

Published finishing positions, with the strengths and considerations from this test. Owner reviews cover other sizes and driving conditions.

1st

Michelin CrossClimate+

+The best balance of performance for the UK climate. Dominated in the dry and wet, and wasn't the worst all season tyre on test in the snow with more than enough performance for the UK winters

−Average curved aquaplaning result.

2nd

Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-2

+The best all season tyre in the snow, excellent wet result, second only to the CrossClimate. Excellent fuel economy.

−Slightly weak in the dry, second to last in dry handling.

3rd

Nokian Weatherproof

+Strongest in snow handling and aquaplaning tests. Excellent rolling resistance.

−Struggled under wet braking.

4th

Nexen N Blue 4 Season

+Low price, excellent in the wet, strong in the dry and snow.

−Last place in both aquaplaning tests.

Read full verdict
5th

Falken EUROALL SEASON AS200

+A solid mid pack performance, with wet handling being a strength.

−Struggled in the snow, noisy.

Read full verdict
6th

Hankook Kinergy 4S

+Asymmetric tread pattern results in strong performance in the dry.

−Last in the snow tests, high rolling resistance.

Read full verdict
7th

Toyo Celsius

+Good snow braking, very low noise.

−Weak in the dry and wet testing. Highest rolling resistance on test.

Read full verdict
8th

Kumho Solus HA31

+Good snow braking.

−Very weak in the wet, weak in the dry.

Read full verdict

Tyre shortlist

Compare selected tyres

2017 Auto Express All Season Tyre Test · 205/55 R16

Explore the complete results →

The full test

The evidence behind the verdict

The 2017 Auto Express all season tyre test is a wonderful mix of eight 205/55 R16 all season tyres, the Dunlop Sport BluResponse summer tyre and the Continental WinterContact TS860 winter tyre.

A new feature for 2017 is wet testing at over, and under the magic 7c mark the tyre manufacturers recommend we change our tyres at.

Both the wet handling and wet braking tests were done at the two different temperatures, and both sets of results presented in full in the magazine. The conclusion? Not much changed between the two temperatures! The Michelin won all four sets of tests, the Kumho lost all four, the winter tyres performance did not change and the summer tyre lost around 1% of it's relative performance as the temperature dropped.

The other big take from the test is something we've also hinted at before. If you want the best "traditional all season" tyre on test, it's not just the Goodyear Vector 4Season Gen-2 you should be considering, but also the Continental WinterContact TS860. It might be classified as a full winter tyre, but its incredible breadth of performance make it as much a traditional all season tyre as any of the tyres included in this test.

Results

As per our agreement with Auto Express, you will only find very limited coverage below, so be sure to head over to the Auto Express website for full details!

1st

Michelin CrossClimate+

205/55 R16
Michelin CrossClimate+
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry300
Wet570.7
Snow365.1
Rolling Resistance93.1
Noise99.1
Overall100

Total: 1528

2nd

Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-2

205/55 R16
Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-2
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry287.1
Wet567.5
Snow397.5
Rolling Resistance98
Noise98.2
Overall99.2

Total: 1547.5

3rd

Nokian Weatherproof

205/55 R16
Nokian Weatherproof
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry283.5
Wet567.9
Snow395.8
Rolling Resistance11
Noise99.5
Overall99.1

Total: 1456.8

4th

Nexen N Blue 4 Season

205/55 R16
Nexen N Blue 4 Season
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry287.9
Wet549.6
Snow382.5
Rolling Resistance86.3
Noise99.8
Overall98.3

Total: 1504.4

5th

Falken EUROALL SEASON AS200

205/55 R16
Falken EUROALL SEASON AS200
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry286.6
Wet556.7
Snow364.7
Rolling Resistance86.6
Noise98.9
Overall97.7

Total: 1491.2

6th

Hankook Kinergy 4S

205/55 R16
Hankook Kinergy 4S
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry287.8
Wet563.3
Snow364.1
Rolling Resistance82.7
Noise99.1
Overall97.5

Total: 1494.5

7th

Toyo Celsius

205/55 R16
Toyo Celsius
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry280.3
Wet540
Snow372.2
Rolling Resistance81.7
Noise100
Overall96.4

Total: 1470.6

8th

Kumho Solus HA31

205/55 R16
Kumho Solus HA31
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry281.1
Wet526.8
Snow378.8
Rolling Resistance82.9
Noise99.2
Overall95.9

Total: 1464.7

Reference Tyre

Reference Summer

205/55 R16
Reference Summer
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry306.8
Wet559
Snow187.9
Rolling Resistance105.2
Noise99.1
Overall96.7

Total: 1354.7

Reference Tyre

Reference Winter

205/55 R16
Reference Winter
All discipline results (6)
TestResult
Dry290
Wet589
Snow400.8
Rolling Resistance99.8
Noise100.1
Overall101.2

Total: 1580.9

More tyre tests

Cross-check this test

All tyre tests

Where these tyres were tested again, and how the verdict held up.

Discussion

19 comments
  1. Gov archived

    I had Vredestein Quatrac 3 and Quatrac 5. I went to get them here in NL at the end of november 2010 (QT3) and there was 10 cm snow with -5 C. went into a wrong b-road and got into serious trouble with the brand new summertires on them. Car: Toyota Corolla VVti 1.6 btw (latest version back then).
    So when I returned with the QT3 underneath the car, I of course went into the same road. Teh difference was spectacular. Went from SW Netherlands to Copenhagen near Christmas 2010. We had 20-30 cm snow and while most other parts had less, there was always snow on the road and temperatures between -3 and -8 C. The car behave great. Only in the Danish capital snow had tuned to pure ice and here there was a huge loss in grip.
    So in 2014 QT 5 were fitted after 60K on the front, the back were QT3. Result on ice: much more grip with the QT5.
    And now all have been changed into Goodyear vector4seasons gen2. These are extremely silent! My GF noted it immediately. On snow and slush however, my first experience the last week here in The Netherlands) with temperatures near freezing is that they seem to feel less steady than the Vredesteins. Much to my surprise. This is in thesize 195/60/15 88H btw. But it might be that I need to adapt somewhat. On the Vredesteins QT3 and QT5 I can say that the Qt3 version lasted a very long time. The back (I have FW drive) side lasted no less than 110.000 km. The Frontwheel 65.000. QT5 does not seem to have such a long life with 45.000 km on them.
    With the QT5 I went on a steep hill, very steep with lots of snow and had zero problems.
    So a long story short: I am now a little doubtfull if I made the right switch. GY V4season Gen2 seem to be consistently the best in tests, but I have to wait more serous snowfall to conclude. Well I can say they are of course far superior to any summertyre. On the QT5 Vredesteins I can say in 7 years and lots of drving in lots and lots of snow: they never ever failed me or gave me an insecure feeling. May be next time the QT7 will be my next tyre. The Michelins for me are not good enough in snow from tests. I am not too fond of companies that have always said allseasons are no good until they come out with their own version and now all of a sudden make a u-turn here. So not too sympathetic towards Michelin, which of ourse has little to do with how good their allseason performs.

    #3089
  2. John archived

    Hi, what about Kleber Quadraxer 2? I need new tyres 245 45 r18, but can't decide...

    #3037
    1. Kolemjdouci John archived

      Also good, new model.

      #3048
  3. MO AMRAN archived

    Vresedestein Quatrac 5. Much underrepresented and underrated. Just changed from falken all season. Difference is night and day. It’s on a tiddly Yaris 1.3! . Wear very good. Still got 5mm + after gentle 8k miles around town. BTW also run hankook a/s tyres on 320d . They are almost on par with vredestein and wear also very good ~ 5mm after 7k miles. Both tyres are very progressive!

    #3011
    1. TyreReviews MO AMRAN archived

      It's a shame the Quatrac 5 wasn't included in this test, it would have been great to see how it did.

      #3012
      1. Kiril Georgiev TyreReviews archived

        They have been featured in other 2017 tests (not sure if I am allowed to post a link to a russian website similar to this one). On one of them they are 4th place after CrossClimate+, Vector Gen2 and Nokian Weatherproof. On another one 6th and third one was a summer test where they are not recommended.

        #3015
            1. TyreReviews Kiril Georgiev archived

              We've covered all but one of those :) The Auto Navigator test didn't really have a strong conclusion, but looking at the data and how we can now present live charts I'll aim to cover it next week

              #3018
    2. Gov MO AMRAN archived

      I used them for years. Excellent tyres. Still went for GY 4seasons Gen2. Wait and see. first indications are ot better than Vredestien actually. But very silent! If I had to make the call right now, I would have chosen the Vredestein but it is very early days. Just 2 days on 10 cm snow, slush and iced up roads....

      #3090
      1. MO AMRAN Gov archived

        Good choice. I think vehicle weight and driven wheels have to be taken into consideration too. I run Dunlop winter sport 4d on Gt86 in cooler months. Goodyear eagle f1 asym 3 in warmer months. Worth it if you have space to store spare wheels as you effectively get twice the longevity!

        #3091
        1. Gov MO AMRAN archived

          Problem here in NL is that each time your chnge your tires you have to pay for the calibration of the pressuresensors which costs you (I think) 50 euro..per tyre. Times two = 400 a year. During the lifespan of your tyres (your mileage as they say may vary) that is 1600 euro. No thanks.
          I drove with QT5 on 30 cm in my flatland NL for weeks I go to the nearby Ardennes where I drove on steep hills and up to 50 cm of snow. I never ever encountered any problem. The best winter and the best summertyre will do better than an allseason like the Goodyear for sure. But not by much and not enough for me. And as a winterweather and snowweatherfreak I drive a lot on snow. And as a stormchaser in summer I drive through heavy downpours.To each their own and good there are choses we can make. Why don't you use allseasons btw? Just interested. Thx for your reply!

          #3092
  4. fabiavrs635 archived

    Shame the Conti AllSeasonContact missed the cut, it feels extremely well suited so far to British Autumnal weather. If I only used one set of rubber year round it would be a pair of these and a pair of Michelin CrossClimate and just switch axles April and November on a FWD car.

    #3009
  5. Igor archived

    I also believe cold weather test are at around 4-5, and other tests are not more than 15 degrees. That's why there are almost no differences in the results.

    #3001
  6. George archived

    Over and under 7. More specific? 8 and 6 degrees? :)
    It's hard to believe that there is no difference in 30 and 0 degrees wet handling/braking.

    #3000
    1. TyreReviews George archived

      Sadly the magazines don't publish the temperatures, but I know in the past getting wet testing below 3c is difficult due to freezing. Our own testing has found summer tyres performance doesn't degrade much between 7c and 3c.

      #3002
      1. George TyreReviews archived

        Between 7 and 3 I can understand.
        But as I said, it would be very interesting to find out how different types of tyres (winter, summer, all season) handle and brake at different temperatures (as low as - 20, 0, to 20, 40 degrees) on wet and dry.
        For a test like that I would actually pay to see the results. :)

        #3003
        1. TyreReviews George archived

          Good luck finding wet testing at -20c, water tends to turn into ice ;)

          #3004
Rate your tyres

My tyres

Saved in this browser on this site. No account needed. Clearing browser data removes your choices.

Vehicle and size

Check the size, load and speed ratings on your vehicle. Saving a size does not confirm fitment.

Saved tyres

Save tyres from a tyre page, test or comparison to keep them here.

Select 2–8 saved tyres. Ranked comparisons require at least two shared tests.

Where to buy

Affiliate links: if you buy, we may earn a commission. It never changes our tests, scores or recommendations. How we stay independent