Menu

Test source Auto Bild

2018 51 Winter Tyre Shootout

Overall test winnerContinental WinterContact TS 860

This year AutoBild have placed 51 195/65 R15 winter tyres through wet braking tests, with the top thirty tyres also being tested for snow braking performance.

Tyres tested
51
Tested size
195/65 R15

At a glance

Tyre shortlist

51 Tyres tested

Published finishing positions, with the strengths and considerations from this test. Owner reviews cover other sizes and driving conditions.

9th

Uniroyal MS plus 77

12th

Barum Polaris 3

14th

Nokian WR D4

15th

Gislaved Euro*Frost 6

16th

Matador MP92 Sibir Snow

17th

Michelin Alpin 5

21st

Nexen Winguard Snow'G WH2

23rd

Kumho WinterCraft WP51

24th

Giti GitiWinter W1

25th

Cooper Weather-Master SA2+

30th

Westlake SW608

34th

Dayton DW510 EVO

40th

Nankang SV2

Joint45th

Syron Everest 1+

51st

Antares Grip 20

Tyre shortlist

Compare selected tyres

2018 51 Winter Tyre Shootout · 195/65 R15

TyreContinental WinterContact TS 860
Fulda Kristall Control HP2
Goodyear UltraGrip 9
Hankook Winter i cept RS2
Dunlop Winter Sport 5
Kleber Krisalp HP3
Pirelli Cinturato Winter
Semperit Master Grip 2
Uniroyal MS plus 77
Bridgestone Blizzak LM001 EVO
Falken Eurowinter HS01
Barum Polaris 3
Debica Frigo HP2
Nokian WR D4
Gislaved Euro*Frost 6
Matador MP92 Sibir Snow
Michelin Alpin 5
Vredestein Snowtrac 5
Firestone Winterhawk 3
Yokohama BluEarth*Winter V905
Nexen Winguard Snow'G WH2
Apollo Alnac 4G Winter
Kumho WinterCraft WP51
Giti GitiWinter W1
Cooper Weather-Master SA2+
Toyo Snowprox S943
Maxxis Arctictrekker WP05
Goodride SW608
Aoteli Aoteli Ecosnow
Westlake SW608
Imperial Snowdragon HP
Lassa Snoways 3
Tomket Snowroad 3
Dayton DW510 EVO
Kenda Wintergen 2 KR501
Fortuna Fortuna Winter
Minerva Frostrack HP
Tristar Snowpower HP
King Meiler Winter Tact WT81
Nankang SV2
Star Performer SPTS Winter AS
Compasal Iceblazer II
Laufenn I FIT
Meteor Meteor Winter
Syron Everest 1+
Taurus Winter 601
Momo North Pole W1
Chengshan Montice CSC 901
Zenises zTyre Z8 Winter
Maxtrek TREK M7
Antares Grip 20
Position1st2nd3rd4th5th6th7th8th9th10th11th12th13th14th15th16th17th18th19th20th21st22nd23rd24th25th26th27th28th29th30th31st32nd33rd34th35th36th37th38th39th40th41st42nd43rd44thJoint 45th46th47th48th49th50th51st
Keep researchingRead owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results
Read owner reviews
Test Results

Explore the complete results →

The full test

The evidence behind the verdict

Update: The full test is now live here.

This year AutoBild have placed 51 195/65 R15 winter tyres through wet braking tests, with the top thirty tyres also being tested for snow braking performance. Only the top twenty have gone through to the full Auto Bild winter tyre test!

With the best winter tyre on test stopping the VW Golf in 34.3 meters, and the worst tyre on test at 49.8 meters, you can see why it's extremely important to judge a winter tyres performance as much on wet grip as it is snow grip.

The full results of the top 20 winter tyre test will be on the site in the next few weeks so be sure to come back!

Results

1st

Continental WinterContact TS 860

195/65 R15
Continental WinterContact TS 860
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet34.5
Snow27.6

Total: 62.1

2nd

Fulda Kristall Control HP2

195/65 R15
Fulda Kristall Control HP2
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet34.8
Snow27.6

Total: 62.4

3rd

Goodyear UltraGrip 9

195/65 R15
Goodyear UltraGrip 9
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet35.5
Snow27

Total: 62.5

4th

Hankook Winter i cept RS2

195/65 R15
Hankook Winter i cept RS2
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet34.9
Snow27.7

Total: 62.6

5th

Dunlop Winter Sport 5

195/65 R15
Dunlop Winter Sport 5
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet34.8
Snow28.1

Total: 62.9

6th

Kleber Krisalp HP3

195/65 R15
Kleber Krisalp HP3
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet35.9
Snow27.1

Total: 63

7th

Pirelli Cinturato Winter

195/65 R15
Pirelli Cinturato Winter
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet35.9
Snow27.4

Total: 63.3

8th

Semperit Master Grip 2

195/65 R15
Semperit Master Grip 2
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet35.9
Snow27.4

Total: 63.3

9th

Uniroyal MS plus 77

195/65 R15
Uniroyal MS plus 77
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet36.1
Snow27.9

Total: 64

10th

Bridgestone Blizzak LM001 EVO

195/65 R15
Bridgestone Blizzak LM001 EVO
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet34.3
Snow29.8

Total: 64.1

11th

Falken Eurowinter HS01

195/65 R15
Falken Eurowinter HS01
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet36.2
Snow28

Total: 64.2

12th

Barum Polaris 3

195/65 R15
Barum Polaris 3
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet36.7
Snow27.8

Total: 64.5

13th

Debica Frigo HP2

195/65 R15
Debica Frigo HP2
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet36.6
Snow28.1

Total: 64.7

14th

Nokian WR D4

195/65 R15
Nokian WR D4
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet37.3
Snow27.6

Total: 64.9

15th

Gislaved Euro*Frost 6

195/65 R15
Gislaved Euro*Frost 6
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet37
Snow28.1

Total: 65.1

16th

Matador MP92 Sibir Snow

195/65 R15
Matador MP92 Sibir Snow
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet36.6
Snow28.6

Total: 65.2

17th

Michelin Alpin 5

195/65 R15
Michelin Alpin 5
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet37.1
Snow28.4

Total: 65.5

18th

Vredestein Snowtrac 5

195/65 R15
Vredestein Snowtrac 5
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet38
Snow27.9

Total: 65.9

19th

Firestone Winterhawk 3

195/65 R15
Firestone Winterhawk 3
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet38.2
Snow27.8

Total: 66

20th

Yokohama BluEarth*Winter V905

195/65 R15
Yokohama BluEarth*Winter V905
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet36.6
Snow29.5

Total: 66.1

21st

Nexen Winguard Snow'G WH2

195/65 R15
Nexen Winguard Snow'G WH2
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet36.8
Snow29.4

Total: 66.2

22nd

Apollo Alnac 4G Winter

195/65 R15
Apollo Alnac 4G Winter
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet37.8
Snow28.7

Total: 66.5

23rd

Kumho WinterCraft WP51

195/65 R15
Kumho WinterCraft WP51
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet38.8
Snow28

Total: 66.8

24th

Giti GitiWinter W1

195/65 R15
Giti GitiWinter W1
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet38.9
Snow28

Total: 66.9

25th

Cooper Weather-Master SA2+

195/65 R15
Cooper Weather-Master SA2+
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet37
Snow30.1

Total: 67.1

26th

Toyo Snowprox S943

195/65 R15
Toyo Snowprox S943
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet36.7
Snow30.6

Total: 67.3

27th

Maxxis Arctictrekker WP05

195/65 R15
Maxxis Arctictrekker WP05
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet39.4
Snow28.3

Total: 67.7

28th

Goodride SW608

195/65 R15
Goodride SW608
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet37.5
Snow31.3

Total: 68.8

29th

Aoteli Aoteli Ecosnow

195/65 R15
Aoteli Aoteli Ecosnow
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet38.9
Snow30.6

Total: 69.5

30th

Westlake SW608

195/65 R15
Westlake SW608
All discipline results (2)
TestResult
Wet39
Snow30.6

Total: 69.6

31st

Imperial Snowdragon HP

195/65 R15
Imperial Snowdragon HP
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet39.8

Total: 39.8

32nd

Lassa Snoways 3

195/65 R15
Lassa Snoways 3
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet40

Total: 40

33rd

Tomket Snowroad 3

195/65 R15
Tomket Snowroad 3
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet40.2

Total: 40.2

34th

Dayton DW510 EVO

195/65 R15
Dayton DW510 EVO
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet40.3

Total: 40.3

35th

Kenda Wintergen 2 KR501

195/65 R15
Kenda Wintergen 2 KR501
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet40.9

Total: 40.9

36th

Fortuna Fortuna Winter

195/65 R15
Fortuna Fortuna Winter
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet41.6

Total: 41.6

37th

Minerva Frostrack HP

195/65 R15
Minerva Frostrack HP
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet41.7

Total: 41.7

38th

Tristar Snowpower HP

195/65 R15
Tristar Snowpower HP
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet42

Total: 42

39th

King Meiler Winter Tact WT81

195/65 R15
King Meiler Winter Tact WT81
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet42.5

Total: 42.5

40th

Nankang SV2

195/65 R15
Nankang SV2
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet42.5

Total: 42.5

41st

Star Performer SPTS Winter AS

195/65 R15
Star Performer SPTS Winter AS
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet42.5

Total: 42.5

42nd

Compasal Iceblazer II

195/65 R15
Compasal Iceblazer II
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet43.1

Total: 43.1

43rd

Laufenn I FIT

195/65 R15
Laufenn I FIT
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet43.2

Total: 43.2

44th

Meteor Meteor Winter

195/65 R15
Meteor Meteor Winter
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet43.3

Total: 43.3

Joint 45th

Syron Everest 1+

195/65 R15
Syron Everest 1+
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet43.7

Total: 43.7

Joint 45th

Syron Everest 1+

195/65 R15
Syron Everest 1+
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet43.7

Total: 43.7

46th

Taurus Winter 601

195/65 R15
Taurus Winter 601
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet43.7

Total: 43.7

47th

Momo North Pole W1

195/65 R15
Momo North Pole W1
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet44

Total: 44

48th

Chengshan Montice CSC 901

195/65 R15
Chengshan Montice CSC 901
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet45.5

Total: 45.5

49th

Zenises zTyre Z8 Winter

195/65 R15
Zenises zTyre Z8 Winter
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet45.5

Total: 45.5

50th

Maxtrek TREK M7

195/65 R15
Maxtrek TREK M7
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet46.7

Total: 46.7

51st

Antares Grip 20

195/65 R15
Antares Grip 20
All discipline results (1)
TestResult
Wet49.8

Total: 49.8

More tyre tests

Cross-check this test

All tyre tests

Where these tyres were tested again, and how the verdict held up.

Discussion

21 comments
  1. Jonathan Fabian archived

    Here's one I haven't seen addressed ref winter tyres.

    With most UK drivers who swap to winters and may not cover more than 2,500 miles over the three months or so they have them on, what's your view as to how many seasons or specifically how many years is it safe to keep and use them?

    If they are stored well, do the usual rules over tyre deg and UV aging apply?

    My Hankooks are just 4 years old and about to go on their 5th winter with perhaps 10,000 miles and little wear on them (as you drive well within limits in the winter) but your advice appreciated on how many more winters I should safely use them?

    Cheers

    #5165
  2. audiohobby archived

    Hi,
    Can you please recommend Winter or Summer tyres that will lean more towards
    All-Seasons types tyres. For my car it`s hard to find all seasons in the size of 245/40 high. Thanks!

    #4248
    1. TyreReviews audiohobby archived

      I'm afraid there's no summer tyres which will work in the snow and ice, and there's no winter tyres which will be great in the warmer dry conditions, where they can give up 20% dry braking. You might need to run two sets!

      #4249
  3. Car Man archived

    Have you considered looking into the consequences of using different tyres in the same brand and model range? What happens when you chose a slightly smaller/larger size or chose a higher loadindex? Sometimes you can't find the tyre you want in the proper size or the tyre is just cheaper. Of course I do mean that it should still work, circumference of the tyre should be within 2% of the original (right?) and it should fit on the rim.

    #4093
    1. TyreReviews Car Man archived

      We've done wheel size and tyre width tests (on youtube and the site), but in the UK you start getting into insurance issues changing tyre sizes, plus you can start the tyre rubbing on various bits of bodywork, so it's not something we ever advise you do. Always stick with OE.

      #4094
      1. Car Man TyreReviews archived

        Thanks for the response. Yeah, I'm not from the UK so didn't know that. I don't believe this is an issue on the other side of the Chanel in the Netherlands.

        I've seen that video, but forgot about most of it. Rewatched it now and as I understand it changing to a slightly smaller width will give you less grip in de dry and more in the wet, but both also just slightly. Can I conclude that it is fine to go for it if the pricing is very different? I did mean it exactly as you chose the tyres in the video, keeping the overall diameter/hight of the tyre (almost) the same. But for me it would be a choice between 185/60 R15 and 175/65 R15.
        Maybe in theory you could chose between

        - A smaller width tyre with more grip in the dry and less in the wet

        - A wider tyre with less grip in the dry and more in the wet giving them both similar performance

        What I'm also wondering is if it will have any consequences if you chose tyres with a different load or speed index (always higher then standard of course)? I can see that some of the same tyres with just a different loadindex have different EU labels.
        I will give you an example:
        2 Good Year Ultragip 9 tyres, both 185/60 R15 ..T tyres
        Only the loadindex is different: 84 or 88
        The 84 has the label E (fuel economy) - B (wet grip) - 68 dB
        The 88 has the label C (fuel economy) - C (wet grip) - 68 dB
        This is kind of weird to me, I also don't always trust this label as it often is different to most tests?

        Ps. I have already ordered 4 new tyres, Good Year Ultragrip 9 in the size 185/60 R15 84T. This is the original tyre size, but I still am interested in answers to the above as I will be buying many more tyres in the future :)

        #4095
        1. TyreReviews Car Man archived

          Honestly, the differences between the two sizes would be so small in the real world I'm not sure I'd worry about it. As said, I'd always prefer to stick with OE sizes where possible, even if that means getting the second choice of rubber.

          #4097
  4. Vlad Toma archived

    The results are those that I expected. For sure, Continental will remain, after full results, the winner of the tests. The rest of the hierarchy will be modified. I'm sure that Nokian will remain somewhere around 10th place, good at snow traction, but week at wet braking, durability and price. Michelin also around 10th place. Pirelli, Uniroyal and Fulda will drop few places, in particular Pirelli. The "real" tyres demonstrates once again their real abilities. By "real" I reffer to really good tyres at a fair price. In this category I include Kleber, Fulda, Barum, and Debica. Winter tyres category. Anyway, the perfect tyre doesn't exists. Good to be fitted by geographic area (weather conditions), driving style, car type and so on

    #3893
    1. TyreReviews Vlad Toma archived

      Great comment :) And your guesses of the final results are really close! Full article on the site next week :)

      #3899
  5. Pedro Neves archived

    Have you ever considered testing which is best in the wet: worn tyres in front and new tyres on the back (same brand and model) or vice versa (either summer or winter tyres)? Wet braking, cornering and aquaplaning tests would be very interesting.
    There are a few videos on Youtube about the subject but they used old cars (with no ESP) with rear wheel drive. With those experiments, in the past, there was the belief that the best combination is worn tyres in front due to handling (with easy oversteer otherwise) but nowadays, with every car equipped with ESP it must be somehow different. Braking, which was never tested, should be much better with the worn tyres in the back if you consider that way over 50% of the emergency braking force is applied to the front wheels and, if you consider aquaplaning (straight and curved), that the front wheels clean up the pavement for the rear tyres to roll on and the ESP is always backing you up (or maybe not...).
    It would be better to test them with a front wheel drive car since these are the majority on the road today.
    It should also be interesting to test them in the dry, not to mention in the snow.
    It must be easy for you to borrow used tyres (but not damaged) in a tyre shop...

    #3884
    1. TyreReviews Pedro Neves archived

      A good idea for a video, I'll add it to the list. The tyre manufacturers still recommend newest on the front for a good reason, and that's aquaplaning. All the electronics in the world can't help you if the tyre is floating, and that's easier and safer to manage with the front end floating rather than the rear.

      Still, all good points and I'll put it on the list :)

      #3892
      1. Pedro Neves TyreReviews archived

        Sorry, did you mean manufacturers recommend newest on the front or on the rear?

        #3894
          1. Pedro Neves TyreReviews archived

            So, it makes sense after all, and regardless some old tests, to install newest on the front.
            Due to low budgets, some drivers consider buying 4 new but cheap tyres instead of 2 new renowned brand tyres and keep for a while the other 2 old but renowned branded tyres on their cars.
            How about adding to the wet test a comparison between 2 new in the front vs 2 old in the front versus 4 new but low budget tyres like: Infinity Ecosis, Matador, Cooper Zeon, Dayton Touring, Nankang Green Sport, GT Radial Champiro, Laufenn S Fit, Rottalla or even the more popular (but also terrible in the wet) Maxxis?

            #3901
            1. TyreReviews Pedro Neves archived

              As every tyre performs differently when worn I'm not sure how much solid data we'd get from a test like that, however I would like to do a video on mix fitment of premium vs budgets, for instance on a rwd car with premium tyres on the front and budgets on the rear. I've done that test before and it's quite scary!

              #3902
              1. Pedro Neves TyreReviews archived

                That's a great ideia for a video, as well! Actually it's a very real cenario that most of the drivers face. They make an effort to buy the most sporty and expensive car they can (even second hand) but then realize they can't afford new tyres because they are simply too expensive.
                It's particularlly frequent on SUVs too. I've seen Volvos XC-60 with ridicularlly cheap tyres. Why would they buy such safe cars like that to install dangerous tyres afterwards!... It can't be just ignorance!
                I've even seen that on Nissans Qashqai and it's a much cheaper car.
                If you're still thinking in testing worn vs new (front vs rear installation) just make sure you go for great wet perfoming tyres like Continentals (PC5 or PC6), Michelin PS4, Goodyear Eagle F1 Assim 3 or maybe Falken FK510. I would suggest 16 inch wheels or 18, particularlly this one, where tyres begin to get quite expensive.

                #3903
      2. pete9501 TyreReviews archived

        Whilst I appreciate Tyre Reviews test a huge number of tyres in different senarios each year, I am afraid that new tyres should go on the rear. Please see the Auto Express review were they tested a couple of Golfs with new on the front and new on the rear. Huge difference. So if you are only replacing a pair, then the new tyres need to go on the rear. FWD, RWD or 4x4 it doesn't make a difference.

        #9661
        1. TyreReviews pete9501 archived

          You are correct, I the first 'front' should be 'rear', what a typo

          #9671
          1. pete9501 TyreReviews archived

            Don't worry, we have all done it, thank you for the reviews, very interesting. Pete, Portsmouth UK.

            #9676
  6. Thierry Priem archived

    Which 3 series did they use? An E9X or F3X has at least 16"...

    #3876
    1. TyreReviews Thierry Priem archived

      You make an excellent point - they used a VW Golf, I'm struggling a little with jetlag today!

      #3877
Rate your tyres

My tyres

Saved in this browser on this site. No account needed. Clearing browser data removes your choices.

Vehicle and size

Check the size, load and speed ratings on your vehicle. Saving a size does not confirm fitment.

Saved tyres

Save tyres from a tyre page, test or comparison to keep them here.

Select 2–8 saved tyres. Ranked comparisons require at least two shared tests.

Where to buy

Affiliate links: if you buy, we may earn a commission. It never changes our tests, scores or recommendations. How we stay independent