Test Publication:
225/45 R17
45 tyres
2 categories
Images courtesy of Auto Bild
Test Publication:
Images courtesy of Auto Bild
Test Size:
225/45 R17
Tyres Tested:
45 tyres
Following on from the
All Season tyre market overview , Auto Bild have published their winter version of the shootout style braking test.
For the winter test, Auto Bild have tested 53 winter tyres in 225/45 R17 in wet and snow braking. The two braking distances are combined, and the top twenty tyres go through to a full test covering all aspects of a tyres performance.
Not for the first time this year, a Bridgestone tyre tops the wet braking test, and wins the overall combined braking distance to finish in the top spot. We're not yet sure what Bridgestone have changed recently, but they've made a massive step forward in the wet, and it will be interesting to see if they can hold onto this performance in the full test.
The "best of the rest" during wet braking testing went to three of the newest tyres on test, the Michelin Alpin 6, Goodyear Ultragrip Performance+ and the Vredestein Wintrac Pro. The Goodyear and Michelin managed to match the performance in the snow, finishing second and third overall.
As always, the tyres at the cheaper end of the spectrum could manage either a reasonable result in the wet, or the snow, but not both, with the worst tyre during wet braking taking a huge ten meters further to stop than the best.
Wet
Snow
Results
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
1st
29.2 M
100%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
10th
24.6 M
24 M
+0.6 M
97.56%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
3rd
30.6 M
29.2 M
+1.4 M
95.42%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
5th
24.3 M
24 M
+0.3 M
98.77%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
2nd
30.4 M
29.2 M
+1.2 M
96.05%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
13th
24.7 M
24 M
+0.7 M
97.17%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
9th
31.6 M
29.2 M
+2.4 M
92.41%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
5th
24.3 M
24 M
+0.3 M
98.77%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
7th
31.5 M
29.2 M
+2.3 M
92.7%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
9th
24.5 M
24 M
+0.5 M
97.96%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
4th
30.8 M
29.2 M
+1.6 M
94.81%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
20th
25.2 M
24 M
+1.2 M
95.24%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
11th
32 M
29.2 M
+2.8 M
91.25%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
4th
24.2 M
24 M
+0.2 M
99.17%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
13th
32.2 M
29.2 M
+3 M
90.68%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
1st
24 M
100%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
5th
31.2 M
29.2 M
+2 M
93.59%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
19th
25.1 M
24 M
+1.1 M
95.62%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
7th
31.5 M
29.2 M
+2.3 M
92.7%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
15th
24.8 M
24 M
+0.8 M
96.77%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
13th
32.2 M
29.2 M
+3 M
90.68%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
10th
24.6 M
24 M
+0.6 M
97.56%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
11th
32 M
29.2 M
+2.8 M
91.25%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
17th
24.9 M
24 M
+0.9 M
96.39%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
18th
32.9 M
29.2 M
+3.7 M
88.75%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
5th
24.3 M
24 M
+0.3 M
98.77%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
17th
32.8 M
29.2 M
+3.6 M
89.02%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
10th
24.6 M
24 M
+0.6 M
97.56%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
19th
33 M
29.2 M
+3.8 M
88.48%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
13th
24.7 M
24 M
+0.7 M
97.17%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
6th
31.3 M
29.2 M
+2.1 M
93.29%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
24th
26.4 M
24 M
+2.4 M
90.91%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
22nd
33.6 M
29.2 M
+4.4 M
86.9%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
2nd
24.1 M
24 M
+0.1 M
99.59%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
21st
33.5 M
29.2 M
+4.3 M
87.16%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
5th
24.3 M
24 M
+0.3 M
98.77%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
27th
34.2 M
29.2 M
+5 M
85.38%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
2nd
24.1 M
24 M
+0.1 M
99.59%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
16th
32.5 M
29.2 M
+3.3 M
89.85%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
22nd
26 M
24 M
+2 M
92.31%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
23rd
33.9 M
29.2 M
+4.7 M
86.14%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
18th
25 M
24 M
+1 M
96%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
27th
34.2 M
29.2 M
+5 M
85.38%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
15th
24.8 M
24 M
+0.8 M
96.77%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
15th
32.4 M
29.2 M
+3.2 M
90.12%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
26th
27 M
24 M
+3 M
88.89%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
27th
34.2 M
29.2 M
+5 M
85.38%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
21st
25.5 M
24 M
+1.5 M
94.12%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
23rd
33.9 M
29.2 M
+4.7 M
86.14%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
23rd
26.1 M
24 M
+2.1 M
91.95%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
10th
31.9 M
29.2 M
+2.7 M
91.54%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
28th
28.3 M
24 M
+4.3 M
84.81%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
26th
34 M
29.2 M
+4.8 M
85.88%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
25th
26.7 M
24 M
+2.7 M
89.89%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
30th
34.3 M
29.2 M
+5.1 M
85.13%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
27th
27.3 M
24 M
+3.3 M
87.91%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
20th
33.4 M
29.2 M
+4.2 M
87.43%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
29th
28.7 M
24 M
+4.7 M
83.62%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
23rd
33.9 M
29.2 M
+4.7 M
86.14%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Snow Braking
30th
31.7 M
24 M
+7.7 M
75.71%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
31st
34.7 M
29.2 M
+5.5 M
84.15%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
32nd
34.8 M
29.2 M
+5.6 M
83.91%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
32nd
34.8 M
29.2 M
+5.6 M
83.91%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
34th
34.9 M
29.2 M
+5.7 M
83.67%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
35th
35.1 M
29.2 M
+5.9 M
83.19%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
36th
35.3 M
29.2 M
+6.1 M
82.72%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
37th
35.6 M
29.2 M
+6.4 M
82.02%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
38th
35.8 M
29.2 M
+6.6 M
81.56%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
39th
36.7 M
29.2 M
+7.5 M
79.56%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
41st
36.9 M
29.2 M
+7.7 M
79.13%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
40th
36.8 M
29.2 M
+7.6 M
79.35%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
42nd
37.4 M
29.2 M
+8.2 M
78.07%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
43rd
37.6 M
29.2 M
+8.4 M
77.66%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
43rd
37.6 M
29.2 M
+8.4 M
77.66%
Test
#
Result
Best
Diff
%
Wet Braking
45th
39.4 M
29.2 M
+10.2 M
74.11%